All topics

Place Your Bets on the Value-Growth Debate!

  • ,  Chief Executive |
  • 08 Jul 2020
  • Updated 09 Jul 2020

Has the Value Spark Been Snuffed Out Again?

Value investors thought their luck was changing recently as cyclical stocks began to rally (helped by a rebound in the price of oil) as thoughts of a swift economic recovery from the COVID-19 crisis began to crystallise. However, that spark was quickly extinguished as the status quo of growth continuing to outperform value was quickly re-established, with the disparity between the two reaching levels not seen since the Tech Bubble. Reasons for growth's outperformance of value since 2007 are legend, and several of the arguments are re-examined in these papers. 

This collection of papers revisits the question of when (or indeed if) value will come back into fashion, or whether the COVID-19 pandemic will have only strengthened the 13-year long dominance of growth, which has been predicated on several structural shifts. Changes to working, societal and economic behaviour, prompted by the pandemic, have seen digital transformation evolve at unprecedented speed and at scale. Widespread adoption and dependency of tech or digital-based solutions (online shopping, working from home, streaming services) may mean that value will remain unloved for a while longer.

smoke swirl

Fasten Your Value Belt: Growth could take you for a wild ride! (QMA, 2020)

In a new valuation framework, QMA relates valuation multiples to fundamentals and finds that changes in fundamentals affect value and growth stocks quite differently. Noting the extreme relative valuation differentials that exist between growth and value, they argue for a reversion to the mean.

Value in Recessions and Recoveries (Research Affiliates, 2020)

Research Associates notes that certain parts of the market and strategies (including value) perform well in a recovery, irrespective of the cause of any market downturn, and that the value/growth dispersion is as wide as it has ever been.

Value is Dead, Long Live Value (OSAM, 2019)

OSAM notes the prolonged underperformance in value from 2007 and compares it to the period of 1926-41. They suggest that both periods equate to turning points in technological revolutions, where new ideas creatively destroy existing business models.

Beware false prophets and focus on the logic of value (QMA, Jun 2020)

QMA’s CEO Andrew Dyson, muses about whether value has indeed died, or whether it is just taking a break after decades of outperformance.

What's Up With Value? (Federated Hermes blog, Jun 2020)

Steven Chiavarone, Portfolio Manager and Equity Strategist, answers questions about value stocks, structural shifts to markets and the prospects for value investing in a low rate, recessionary environment.

Viral Market Meltdown VIII: Value vs Growth and other debates (Aswath Damodaran, May 2020)

Professor Damodaran involves himself in the value/growth debate and thinks that value investing needs to evolve if it is to get its mojo back.

Is Value Investing Structurally Impaired? (Research Affiliates, Apr 2020)

This Research Affiliates paper dissects value into 3 component parts, suggesting that post-2007 underperformance is largely a function of growth stocks becoming more expensive, (partly a function of low yields) rather than anything ‘broken’ with the value metrics.

Growth vs Value Style in European Equities: Whiplash! (Candriam blog, May 2020)

As economic recovery begins, Candriam warms of a possible rotation into value stocks. However, large tech companies dominate many growth indices, and their superior growth rates may have been further enhanced by COVID-19 induced changes to working, societal and economic activities.

The Presumed End of the Value Premium (StarCapital Research, 2019)

StarCapital dissects some of the ideas behind value’s decline and the rise in growth over the last 13 years, arguing that a low growth, low interest rate environment is not conducive for value stocks. They suggest that value will once again have its ‘time in the sun’, though calling the turn is hard.

The Myth of Value and Growth (Michael Mauboussin, 2020)

Michael Mauboussin dissects how investors actually value companies, noting that many ignore the underlying drivers of businesses and that value and growth distinctions may in fact be muddled.

Does This Recession Favour Growth Stocks? (JP Morgan AM, Jun 2020)

JPM AM notes the dominance of growth stocks and the extreme valuation dispersion that exists between growth and value, questions how defensive some growth company earnings are and observes that a large part of many value indices comprise sectors with declining earnings (financials, oils).

Growth vs Value: Historical perspective (Anchor Capital Advisors, 2020)

This paper from Anchor Capital Advisors examines the outperformance of value over growth across many market cycles, then takes a deeper dive into the latest growth cycle.

Value Trap or Trapped Value? (Franklin Templeton, May 2020)

For compliance reasons, this paper is only accessible in certain geographies

Franklin Templeton argues that due diligence is the only way to differentiate between ‘trapped value’ and ‘value trap’. They note that value and growth are not different investment strategies, as without growth, value creation rarely happens.

Podcast: Why this crisis favours growth stocks (Baillie Gifford, May 2020)

Baillie Gifford partner Tom Slater explains why growth stocks have fared better than value stocks during the coronavirus downturn. Some or all of the companies mentioned in this podcast may be investments in funds managed by Baillie Gifford.

S&P Pure Growth Indices – Attributes and Performance Drivers (S&P Dow Jones blog, Jun 2020)

S&P Dow Jones Indices looks at the key drivers of its Pure Growth Index outperformance, noting that overweighting IT (strong positive) and underweighting financials (strong negative) were the principal components driving performance.

A New Era for Growth Stocks (Federated Hermes blog, May 2020)

Federated Hermes argues for the continuance of the growth investing style, driven by a low growth, low interest rate environment, continuing evolution and innovation by companies and shrinking product lifespans driven by technology.